THE 15 BEST Restaurants in Clayton, NY - With Menus, Reviews, Photos - Updated July 2024 (2024)

Customers` Favorites

“The Clipper Inn offers a delightful dining experience with excellent food and great service. The menu features standout dishes like the 5pm Thai shrimp curry, which comes with black rice and julienne pea pods and carrots. The Inn also offers an early bird special with a glass of wine and salad. The bar serves tasty drinks. The rooms are clean and well-stocked, and while there was a slight issue with the bed sizes, the location is convenient to town.”

Customers` Favorites

“Koffee Kove Restaurant is a warm and welcoming spot for breakfast and lunch, serving solid dishes with creative sandwiches at lunchtime. The pleasant staff provide a friendly atmosphere, making it a popular meeting place in downtown Clayton. While it has undergone changes, including the removal of its vegan menu, the restaurant remains a beloved local staple with a charming ambiance and good food.”

Customers` Favorites

“Tricia's is a small-town diner known for its homey atmosphere and delicious meals. The restaurant offers a variety of breakfast and lunch options, including smothered chicken sandwiches, fish fry, and generous portions of eggs, toast, meats, and home fries. The staff is praised for their friendliness and attentiveness. While the diner's future status is uncertain, it remains a local favorite for those seeking a satisfying and reasonably-priced meal.”

Customers` Favorites

“Coyote Moon Vineyards on the River offers exceptional wine tastings and service. The staff, especially servers Pim and Ashley, go above and beyond to create a fantastic experience for guests. The wines are top-notch, and the view is spectacular. A must-visit if you're in the area!”

Customers` Favorites

“Shipwreck Eatery offers a casual dining experience with a beautiful view of the St. Lawrence River. The menu features fresh and creative dishes, including the Twisted Chef salad and Loaded Grill Cheese sandwich. The service is friendly and quick, and the outdoor patio provides a lovely spot to enjoy a meal or refreshing drink. With a relaxed atmosphere and tasty food, Shipwreck Eatery is a great spot for breakfast or lunch.”

Customers` Favorites

“P J's River Rat Cafe is a friendly restaurant and bar with nice rooms, free WiFi, and cable. The staff is pleasant and efficient, serving homemade-style cooking, including lots of fried fish, at reasonable prices. The menu features a variety of options, including walleye, fish platters, and turkey cutlets, all cooked perfectly. Don't forget to try a slice of homemade pie! The cafe is exceptionally clean, and the service is super friendly, making it a great spot to grab a meal after a day of sightseeing.”

“Clayton Popcorn Company offers a delightful experience with its delicious popcorn flavors, including white cheddar and yellow cheddar. The friendly and welcoming staff provide exceptional customer service, making visitors feel like family. With its perfect flavor profiles and inviting atmosphere, this spot is a must-visit for popcorn lovers.”

Customers` Favorites

“Mar's Pizzeria in Clayton is a local favorite, known for their delicious wings and pizza. The garlic pizza and sweet chili wings are highly recommended. They are accommodating, especially with large orders, making it a go-to spot for many. The staff is friendly and great with kids, making the dining experience enjoyable for families. A must-visit for those craving phenomenal pizza.”

“Kay's Kitchen at Clayton Island Tours offers a friendly and organized service with knowledgeable and entertaining tour guides. The restaurant provides bagged lunches for their boat tours, including a delicious roast beef sandwich and breakfast options. While the prices are slightly higher, customers appreciate the thoughtful reminders from the staff about crossing international areas and the tasty cookies. The highlight of the tour is the stop at Boldt Castle and the Rock Island Lighthouse.”

“Saint Lawrence Spirits Downtown Tasting Room offers a spacious dining area with a fantastic selection of New York craft beverages and spirits. The menu features diverse options, including jumbo-sized chicken wings that are cooked well, though on the pricier side. The friendly and knowledgeable staff make it a must-visit for anyone exploring the 1000 Islands region. Customers praise the cozy atmosphere, excellent liquor, and the staff's willingness to offer tastings to help find the perfect drink.”

“Spokes on the River is a unique venue located on the water with a big gray metal building that houses a cozy bar and seating area. The bar offers creative co*cktails, including the spicy mango mule. The menu features dishes like Smokey Chicken Flat Bread and spicy Italian panini. The staff is friendly and welcoming, making it a great spot to visit and enjoy a meal or drink.”

Customers` Favorites

“Island Bay Pier House is a restaurant known for its delicious food and unique decor. The smoked prime rib is particularly praised as one of the best by those who have tried it. They also offer elegant catering services, as experienced by one wedding party at the Antique Boat Museum. The co*cktails are handcrafted and homemade, making for delightful drinks. With friendly employees and a clean, welcoming environment, Island Bay Pier House is a recommended dining destination.”

“Saint Lawrence Spirits Château offers delightful dishes prepared by a chef who shows dedication to success in both life and career. The leadership and management skills ensure a flawless dining experience. The beautiful location and building complement the generous tasting of spirits. The diverse food menu includes jumbo-sized chicken wings cooked perfectly, and the bartenders serve amazing drinks. With a fantastic selection of NY craft beverages, this restaurant is a must-visit in the 1000 Islands region.”

Customers` Favorites

“The Channelside offers incredibly delicious appetizers like bang bang shrimp and scallops with bacon jam. The tuna poke bowl is a popular entree choice. Despite some delays, the food is great and delicious, with fresh and light options like the perch. The staff is nice and courteous, and the prices are reasonable. The location right on the water provides beautiful views, perfect for a nice day out. The deck might be closed towards the end of the season, but the food, like the veggie burger and sausage sandwich, remains good.”

“Wood Boat Brewery in Clayton is a restaurant and brewery that offers a private event space, ideal for small gatherings. The venue, food, and service have been praised as "amazing" and "perfect" for a rehearsal dinner of 30 people. Kassandra and her team are commended for their excellent work. The wood boat bar is a notable feature. However, dining experience varies, with some visitors experiencing long wait times and inconsistent food quality, especially for barbecue sandwiches and pizzas. It is recommended to sit on the porch to avoid noise, but be aware of bees.”

Customers` Favorites

“Lyric Coffee House is a unique coffee shop located in a historic building, formerly an old theater, that offers a cozy and relaxing atmosphere. They serve a variety of delicious coffee, including their signature Lyric mocha, which can be enjoyed iced or hot. The menu includes tasty breakfast options such as sandwiches and bagels. The shop features a balcony area and a selection of baked goods. It is a wonderful place to spend time sipping coffee and learning about the building's history.”

“Lost Navigator offers a welcoming atmosphere and exceptional hospitality. The friendly staff go above and beyond, even mailing a lost wallet to a customer. While service can be inconsistent, the bar is a great spot to catch a game, enjoy good music, and share stories with locals. With great prices, it's a favorite among regulars, making it a true local watering hole.”

Customers` Favorites

“New Lucky Kitchen is a Chinese restaurant that offers a diverse menu with both hits and misses when it comes to spicy dishes. While some customers find the Dragon & Phoenix dish lacking in spice, they generally enjoy the food and appreciate the quick service and friendly staff. The restaurant caters to a range of tastes, with one customer describing the chicken and broccoli as better than their local Chinese takeout, and the Singapore mei fun as authentic enough to meet their high standards. The online ordering system is also praised as being user-friendly. While the menu may not have a wide selection of vegetarian options, the restaurant is considered a reliable and satisfying choice for those seeking Chinese cuisine in the area.”

Customers` Favorites

“Natali's/C-Way Restaurant & Bar offers a casual, clean decor with delicious food and attentive service. The average price for two entrees and drinks is around $62. The staff, including waitress "T," are friendly and efficient, even during busy times. The menu includes homemade classics like Manacoti with meatballs and Oscar filet, cooked to perfection. The restaurant provides ample parking and a lively atmosphere, making it a great choice for a homestyle, down-to-earth dining experience.”

“Castle Ice Cream offers a vast selection of Perry's ice cream flavors, with generous servings and reasonable prices. The menu boasts a wide range of options, including unique flavors like "Let's Dough Buffalo" and "Grasshopper Pie". Customers can enjoy their treats at a window counter or outdoor picnic tables. With a convenient location, Castle Ice Cream is a great find for those looking for a sweet treat.”

“The Scoop is a comfortable and cute restaurant that smells delicious from the moment you walk in. They offer a variety of goodies, including Mary's Baked Goods, which are fresh and delicious. Their ice cream sundaes are also a hit, with the coffee and donuts sundae being a standout - it tastes just like a cup of coffee with a donut on the side.”

Customers` Favorites

“O'Briens is a casual neighborhood restaurant and bar with good food, fair prices, and friendly service. The atmosphere is lively, with live music that can be loud at times. While the wheelchair accessibility may be a concern, the restaurant is a popular spot for watching out-of-area football games and enjoying a relaxed dining experience.”